Ad imageAd image

What if… Manchester City Have Their Trophies Taken Away from Them?

podiumadmin
181 Views
9 Min Read

Tony Pulis’ Stoke team lost the 2011 FA Cup final to Manchester City Michael Regan – The FA via Getty Images

Ryan Shawcross wipes his hands on his shirt as he walks up the famous Wembley steps, a beaming smile on his face.

Stoke City’s triumphant captain is about to lift only the club’s second major trophy. Their fans belt out one more “Why, why, why Delilah?” as the players form a line for the trophy presentation.

This will be the start of a period of dominance in cup competitions for the club who, buoyed by their FA Cup success and newfound ability to attract higher-profile signings, win the competition in 2012 too, with Romelu Lukaku, the teenage sensation signed from Anderlecht of Belgium, scoring the winner in the final.

Manager Tony Pulis’ approach of a 4-4-2 formation, long throws and playing four centre-backs is replicated across European football, eventually rendering Pep Guardiola’s tiki-taka tactics ineffective and defunct. Pulis moves on to Paris Saint-Germain and wins FIFA’s world coach of the year award in 2014.


What might have been, had Manchester City not begun sweeping all before them, starting with that 2010-11 FA Cup final victory against Stoke?

Well, probably not, but the news that they have been found guilty on almost all of the charges relating to breaches of the Premier League’s financial regulations raises the possibility that more than two dozen titles and trophies could be stripped from them and awarded elsewhere.

Until the sanctions imposed on City are known — punishments such as points deductions, fines and perhaps even relegation have all been mooted — the notion of having to hand back silverware and championships still feels far-fetched. Whether that would be restricted to the Premier League or could extend to other competitions is not known.

However, there is a high-profile precedent in football — the 2006 Calciopoli scandal in Italy, when one of Juventus’ titles was retrospectively awarded to Inter.

Given City won 26 trophies (including four Community Shields and a UEFA Super Cup) between 2011 and 2026, a hefty slice of football history would need rewriting if the full weight of football law were to be thrown at them.

In terms of top-flight titles, City are the fourth-most successful club in the history of English football, with 10 championships, eight of which have been won in the past 15 seasons.

If, for example, those eight titles were to be taken away, City would instantly plummet to joint-15th in the all-time title-winning standings, below Blackburn Rovers, Huddersfield Town and Wolverhampton Wanderers (who have won three league titles each) and level with Portsmouth, Burnley and, yes, Tottenham Hotspur.

If those titles were awarded to the club who finished as runners-up, then the retrospective champions would be Manchester United (2012, 2018 and 2021), Liverpool (2014, 2019 and 2022) and Arsenal (2023 and 2024).

Ole Gunnar Solskjaer and Brendan Rodgers, Premier League title-winning managers? Mikel Arteta, three-time Premier League-winning legend? Jose Mourinho could stick four fingers up during terse press conferences to reference how many English leagues he had won. It would all feel very surreal.

While United, Liverpool and Arsenal winning a few more titles perhaps wouldn’t be that enthralling for neutrals, given their standing as already being the three most successful English clubs, the FA Cup and League Cup throw up some unorthodox names, such as the aforementioned Stoke (2011) and Watford (2019) in the FA Cup, plus Sunderland (2014), Aston Villa (2020) and Spurs (2021) in the League Cup.

None of this may become a reality, but there is a growing clamour from people who represented the runners-up, which in some cases may be tongue-in-cheek but in others is very serious.

Pulis says in his latest BBC Sport column that he now feels cheated out of an FA Cup win.

And here’s Jermaine Pennant, who played the full 90 minutes for Stoke that day…

Former Manchester United players David de Gea and Rio Ferdinand are also keen for another Premier League title…

When Inter were awarded that 2006 Serie A title as part of the Calciopoli scandal, in which Juventus were also relegated to Serie B, it was the club’s first since 1989. While there were feelings of joy, it was a hollow victory for some.

“Juve won that scudetto (champions’ trophy) because they had great players,” Inter striker Alvaro Recoba later said.

“When it came out that the scudetto had been awarded to Inter, I thought the players didn’t feel it was theirs.”

Justice, rather than joy, was the overriding emotion for Inter at that time, reflected by president Giacinto Facchetti’s comments: “This is the scudetto of fairness and respect for the rules. It’s a scudetto that comes at a time when Italian football has decided to put ethics at the centre of everything. For this reason, it’s a scudetto that has a double meaning.”

Manager Roberto Mancini added: “We all know celebrating on the pitch is another thing, but this scudetto must be extra motivation for next season.” It certainly was, as Inter won the 2007 title by 22 points ahead of second-placed Roma, one of the most dominant seasons in modern Serie A history.

In the same year as Inter’s administration title, the winner of the world’s biggest cycling race was also anointed retrospectively. While Lance Armstrong’s seven Tour de France victories were taken from him but not awarded to any of the runners-up, when fellow American Floyd Landis tested positive for drugs, his 2006 yellow jersey passed to Spaniard Oscar Pereiro.

“It was a pity we didn’t know about the positive earlier — the day on the podium could have been the best day of my life,” Pereiro said. “It isn’t the best way to win the Tour, but if I do get it, I will feel proud of what I have achieved.”

There have been numerous cases in track and field of medals retrospectively awarded after athletes were found guilty of doping offences.

Last year, Great Britain’s men’s 4x400m relay team from the 1997 World Championships were finally presented with their gold medals, 28 years after the race. One of America’s quartet, Antonio Pettigrew, had confessed in 2008 to doping during his career but it still took another 17 years for the runners-up to receive their medals, with the British team having mixed feelings about the prospect of a gold medal coming their way during the lengthy legal process.

One of them, Mark Richardson, had said in 2011: “What difference does it make? Does it mean that we get to go up on to the rostrum and savour the moment? No. Does it mean that the race is going to be re-run and we come out victorious? No.”

How much would it really mean for Arsenal to be handed the 2023 Premier League title? Or for Sunderland to lift the 2014 League Cup, 12 years later?

Perhaps little, perhaps a lot, but for the 26 runners-up in the competitions and tournaments won by City in the past 15 years, justice — however hollow — may be all that mat

Source: www.nytimes.com

Stay ahead with the latest updates!

Join The Podium Media on WhatsApp for real-time news alerts, breaking stories, and exclusive content delivered straight to your phone. Don’t miss a headline — subscribe now!

Chat with Us on WhatsApp
Share This Article
Leave a Comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *